The Gilded Age in the Lowcountry

Posted

The recent fourth-season premiere of HBO’s “The Gilded Age” has once again captured the nation’s imagination with the affluence and sophistication of one of America’s most prosperous eras. The show may offer a fictionalized portrait of this unique period, when robber barons, railroad tycoons, savvy industrialists and brilliant inventors helped forge a path into a new century, but the story it tells is very real.

And as it turns out, some of its most fascinating chapters were written right here in Bluffton.

“I had been looking into the Flagers and the Harknesses, but then I heard a podcast that mentioned the ‘Princess’ Henrietta Pollitzer who lived here, and I really started to poke around and try to understand the overlay,” said Bluffton resident Don Schueler.

A nearly lifelong enthusiast of Gilded Age history, Schueler had been compiling histories of the Rockefeller, Flagler and Harkness families, who had built their fortunes in Northern industry, for his website, gildedgreats.com. Finding ties to the area he now called home proved too tantalizing a thread not to follow.

“I knew there were plantations around that people had bought in the Gilded Age, and land that had been purchased as hunting preserves, so I started to piece it all together that way.”

Like the oil barons who had fascinated him since his youth, the exploratory well he sank in Bluffton tapped into an unimaginably deep reservoir of stories.

How the vacuum created by the “Great Skedaddle” of 1861, when the wealthy planter class fled Union cannons, was filled by industrialists in search of cheap land for hunting. How new wealth had claimed old-money plantations such as Rose Hill, Belfair, Chelsea and Spring Island. And how the area would eventually attract more Gilded Age aristocrats, including the “Marrying Wilsons” to Palmetto Bluff, Standard Oil heir Pete Bostwick to Haig Point and Alfred Lee Loomis to Hilton Head Island.

“The connection with Alfred Lee Loomis really surprised me. All the years I lived down here I had no idea that he owned that much of Hilton Head. I knew a lot about him and his contributions to radar and helping win World War II, and always thought he was an interesting character,” Schueler said. “The funny thing is, I was over at Honey Horn in the hunting lodge he’d owned, and they had a big book rack, but not a single copy of (Loomis’ famed biography) ‘Tuxedo Park.’”

Schueler’s longstanding fascination with the Gilded Age, particularly the lasting legacy of Standard Oil and the generational wealth it created, began in his youth in Bellevue, Ohio.

His local YMCA, he discovered, had originally been a grand Victorian mansion donated to the city by a wealthy family. As he pursued a career in information technology, Gilded Age history became his passion, and he found its fingerprints everywhere his career took him, from California, where Pollitzer’s son George Huntington Hartford II had pursued his own fortunes, to Maryland, where Henry Flagler had laid down roots.

“Henry Flagler had built a home in the town where I lived, and as I started doing my research I realized nobody in town really even knew much about it,” he said. “I felt like, since I’m gathering all this data, I may as well make it public.”

Those stories, and the insight they offer into Bluffton and Hilton Head’s history, can be found at gildedgreats.com.

A 20-year Bluffton resident, Barry Kaufman is a freelance writer and editor as well as host of B-Town Trivia. Follow him on Instagram @btownbarry and @btowntrivia.